Metal 3D Printing: When It Wins, and When It Is Expensive Theatre

Nov 17, 2026

Leave a message

Metal 3D Printing: When It Wins, and When It Is Expensive Theatre

Metal additive is a real production process. It is also the most misapplied one in the shop - chosen for parts that a machining centre would make faster, cheaper and more accurately. Here is how to tell the difference.

 

What the process actually is

Almost every "metal 3D printed part" you have held was made by laser powder bed fusion (LPBF, also sold as SLM or DMLS). A thin layer of metal powder, typically 20–60 µm, is spread across a plate. A laser melts the cross-section of the part. The plate drops. Another layer goes down. Repeat a few thousand times.

That is the whole idea. Everything difficult about the process follows from it: the part is built in slices, it is built inside a bed of powder, and it cools at rates that weld metal normally never sees.

3D-51

Process

How it works

Where it fits

Laser powder bed fusion (LPBF)

Laser melts each layer in a powder bed

The default for complex, small-to-medium parts

Electron beam melting (EBM)

Electron beam in vacuum, hot process

Titanium orthopaedics, less residual stress

Directed energy deposition (DED)

Powder or wire fed into a moving melt pool

Large near-net shapes, repair, cladding

Binder jetting

Binder printed into powder, then sintered

High volume small parts, lower cost, more shrinkage

Four processes, four different design rulebooks. This article is mostly about LPBF, because that is what most enquiries mean.

The cost curve is vertical, not by weight

This is the single fact that changes how you design for metal AM.

In machining, cost tracks the material you remove and the time the spindle runs. In LPBF, cost tracks build height and the area the part occupies on the plate. A 200 g part sitting 150 mm tall costs far more than a 400 g part lying 40 mm tall. Weight is almost irrelevant; the machine charges you for vertical space and for the seconds each layer takes.

Three consequences:

1. Lay it down. Re-orient the part so its smallest dimension is vertical, and the price can halve.

2. Fill the plate. Ten parts in one build spread the fixed cost - powder, gas, machine time, one heat treatment - over ten parts. One part alone on a plate carries all of it.

3. Design for the build, not for the drawing. If two parts can share a build by being nested or stacked, that is a cost decision made at the design review.

A supplier who quotes metal AM by weight has not understood their own process.

3D-8

Five signals that metal AM is the right answer

Internal channels that cannot be drilled. Conformal cooling in a mould insert, cooling jackets around a motor, fuel galleries inside a manifold. This is the strongest case, and it has no competitor.

Topology that would need five setups. Organic, load-following shapes with undercuts on every face. Machining them means fixturing each face; printing means one build.

Consolidation. Twelve machined parts, brazed and bolted into one assembly, become one printed part with no joints to leak or fret.

Very small quantities of a complex part. One to fifty pieces of something that would need a casting tool. No tool, no minimum order.

A material that is miserable to machine. Titanium and some nickel alloys cut slowly and wear tools; printing near-net and machining only the interfaces can be cheaper than cutting from solid.

3D-11

Five signals that it is not

The part is basically a block with holes. A machining centre will be faster, cheaper and tighter. Printing it is a way to pay four times more for worse tolerances.

Tolerance matters everywhere. LPBF holds roughly ±0.1 mm, or ±0.2% on larger dimensions, and it varies with orientation. If the whole part needs ±0.02 mm, you are printing a blank and machining it anyway.

Hundreds or thousands of pieces. Beyond a few hundred, casting or forging plus machining wins on unit cost, and metal powder is not cheap.

Large and simple. Build volume is the limit, and a big simple part uses the most expensive real estate in the factory.

Mirror surface or a sealing face as built. As-printed surfaces run around Ra 8–12 µm. Anything better is a machining or polishing operation afterwards.

3D-21

 

Metal AM (LPBF)

CNC machining

Casting + machining

Complexity

Almost free

Costs setups and time

Costs tooling

Geometry freedom

Highest

Limited by the cutter

Limited by draft

Tolerance

±0.1 mm typical

±0.01 mm on critical features

Needs machining allowance

Surface as supplied

Ra 8–12 µm

Ra 1.6 µm or better

Ra 12 µm, then machined

Quantity sweet spot

1–200

1–1,000

500+

Lead time

Days per build

Days

Weeks for tooling

Material waste

Low, but powder handling

High, chips

Medium

The alloys, and what each one is for

Alloy

Character

Typical parts

Post-processing

AlSi10Mg

Light, castable-grade, good thermal

Housings, heat sinks, brackets

Stress relief, optional T6, often machined

Ti-6Al-4V

Strong, corrosion-proof, expensive powder

Aerospace brackets, implants, medical instruments

Stress relief, HIP, machining

316L stainless

Ductile, corrosion resistant, forgiving

Manifolds, food and chemical parts

Stress relief, passivation

17-4PH

High strength after ageing

Tooling, functional prototypes, aerospace fittings

Solution and age, HIP optional

CoCr

Wear and temperature resistant

Medical implants, turbine and wear parts

HIP, heat treat, polishing

Inconel 718

High temperature strength

Hot-section aerospace, energy

Stress relief, HIP, ageing

CuCrZr

High thermal and electrical conductivity

Induction coils, heat sinks, welding electrodes

Heat treat, machining

Two rules of thumb from this table: aluminium is the easiest entry point and the least forgiving on distortion; titanium and nickel are where printing pays for itself, because the alternative is slow cutting.

3D-9

Design rules that actually decide success

Feature

Rule

Why

Overhang

Support needed below about 45° from vertical

Unsupported melt sags and curls

Minimum wall

Around 0.4 mm, 0.6–1.0 mm for load-bearing

Thin walls distort and are hard to clean

Minimum hole

Around 0.5–1.0 mm, and only through-holes

Small bores close up and trap powder

Powder escape

Every hollow needs at least two openings

Trapped powder is a reject, and a hazard

Channel size

1.5 mm and up for reliable powder removal

Narrow channels block during cleaning

Clearance for mating parts

Extra 0.1–0.2 mm on printed fits

Printed surfaces are rougher than machined

Sharp internal corners

Add radii

Stress concentration plus unmelted powder

Datum faces

Design them flat and machinable

They will be machined, so plan for it

The powder escape rule catches more first-time designers than any other. A closed hollow with one small hole looks fine on screen and arrives full of metal powder, or gets drilled open by the supplier - at your cost.

Distortion, stress and heat treatment

LPBF welds metal in thousands of tiny passes. Each pass shrinks as it solidifies, and the part resists. The result is residual stress, which shows up as:

Warping when the part is cut off the plate.

Cracking in stiff, thick sections - particularly in nickel alloys and tool steels.

Movement during machining, so the finished part drifts out of tolerance days later.

The standard answer is a chain, not a single step:

1. Build with support and anchors so the part cannot curl while printing.

2. Stress relief before removal from the plate, in the furnace, while still attached.

3. Remove from the plate by wire EDM or saw, not by force.

4. HIP where the application justifies it - titanium and nickel in fatigue or pressure service. HIP closes internal porosity, but it also moves the part, so it belongs before final machining.

5. Heat treat to the alloy's specification, then machine the datums.

Skipping step 2 is the most common cost-saving mistake, and it usually shows up at the customer, not at the supplier.

3D-10

After the printer: the part is half finished

An as-printed part is a near-net shape. The finishing chain is where the money and the schedule actually go:

Support removal by hand tools, or by machining for critical surfaces.

Wire EDM off the plate to preserve the base flatness.

CNC machining of datums and interfaces - bearing bores, seal faces, threads, dowel holes. This is unavoidable for any part that mates with something else.

Surface finishing by bead blasting, vibratory finishing, polishing or anodising, depending on the alloy.

Cleaning, especially internal channels: ultrasonic, flow check, and for medical or vacuum parts, a documented procedure.

This is why metal AM parts so often come back to a machining centre. The printer makes the shape; the machining centre makes the part usable.

3D-71

Inspection: what to check, and how

Density and porosity - by CT or by destructive section on a witness coupon built with the part.

Internal channels - CT is often the only way to confirm a conformal cooling passage is clear and correctly formed.

Dimensions - CMM on machined features; optical or structured light on freeform surfaces where a probe cannot reach.

Mechanical properties - test coupons built in the same orientation as the part, because orientation changes the result.

Powder and residue - a cleanliness check, particularly for channels and for medical or food-contact parts.

What to send with an enquiry

1. The 3D model, as a solid, with the build orientation you have in mind if you have one.

2. The alloy, and whether an equivalent is acceptable.

3. Which features will be machined after printing, and to what tolerance.

4. The load case or the function - pressure, fatigue, thermal cycling - because it decides heat treatment and HIP.

5. Quantity per year, and whether the part could be redesigned for the process.

6. The inspection and acceptance rules, including any CT or coupon requirements.

That list is short, and most enquiries arrive with only the first item.

 

About the manufacturer

Shenzhen Strongd Model Technology Co., Ltd. is a CNC machining and industrial 3D printing supplier for robotics, automotive, medical and consumer electronics customers. The Shenzhen plant covers 40,000 m² and runs 85 CNC machining centres, 18 of them five-axis, alongside nine industrial polymer printers with builds up to 1,500 × 750 × 550 mm. Inspection uses Hexagon CMM under ISO 9001:2015 and IATF 16949:2016. Prototypes ship in 3–7 days; quotations are returned within 8 working hours.

Website: https://www.strongdcnc.com/

Send Inquiry